10 Best Restaurants in Atlantic Beach, NY

Atlantic Beach, NY, might be small, but its dining scene is anything but. From casual beachside grills to fancy seafood spots, this coastal town serves up flavors that will make your taste buds do a happy dance. Fresh seafood, Italian classics, global tapas—you name it, Atlantic Beach has it. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite after sunbathing or treating yourself to a fancy dinner with an ocean view, these restaurants deliver flavor, fun, and a little bit of local charm.

Grotta di Fuoco, aka “Fire Cave,” is rustic, cozy, and smells amazing—thanks to the wood-burning oven right beside the bar. Perfect for winter nights or anytime you want to feel the warmth while inhaling the irresistible aroma of pizza and pasta.
Famous Dishes: Wood-fired specialties, rustic Italian favorites
Address: 237 Atlantic Ave, Long Beach, NY 11561

Portuguese and Mediterranean vibes hit hard at A Taberna. From frango de churrasco to seafood platters and paella, this spot is like a mini vacation on a plate. Don’t be shy—try something new.
Famous Dishes: Frango de churrasco, seafood platter, Portuguese steak
Address: 17 Park Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

Elegance with an Atlantic view. Atlantica’s seafood and coastal dishes pair perfectly with panoramic ocean vistas. Breakfast, lunch, or dinner—every meal here feels like a mini celebration.
Famous Dishes: Coastal seafood, oceanfront breakfast
Address: 88 W Broadway, Long Beach, NY 11561

Old-school Italian meets modern flair. Chef Gio brings decades of experience and a love for pasta that you can taste in every bite. Bonus: the wine list is legit.
Famous Dishes: Classic Italian entrées, handmade pastas
Address: 209 Park Ave, Atlantic Beach, NY 11509

A Long Beach classic. With daily specials, live music, and a lively bar scene, Minnesota’s keeps it casual but never boring. Comfort food never tasted so good.
Famous Dishes: American comfort dishes, seafood plates
Address: 112 Park Ave, Long Beach, NY 11561

French-inspired steakhouse with kosher cuisine? Yes, please. Prime-aged steaks, fresh seafood, and indulgent desserts make this one fancy but approachable.
Famous Dishes: Prime-aged steaks, French seafood dishes
Address: 25 Central Ave, Lawrence, NY 11559

Spanish vibes, bold flavors, and sangrias that actually make you feel fancy. Add a slice of Tres Leches Coconut cake, and you’re basically in culinary heaven.
Famous Dishes: Paella, Tres Leches Coconut cake
Address: 71 Park Ave, Island Park, NY 11558

Felicia is where small plates meet big flavors. Globally inspired dishes, cocktails that deserve a toast, and a space that’s both stylish and welcoming. Perfect for dates or catching up with friends.
Famous Dishes: Global small plates, artisanal desserts
Address: 45 Park Ave, Long Beach, NY 11561

Sushi lovers, this one’s for you. A 90-minute omakase journey that’s all about precision, freshness, and flavor. It’s fancy, but in a “wow, I’m glad I’m here” way.
Famous Dishes: Omakase sushi selection, curated nigiri, sashimi
Address: 107 Atlantic Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563

Neighborhood charm meets Mediterranean-inspired cuisine. Seasonal ingredients, fresh seafood, and an atmosphere that’s cozy but never boring. AURA is great for casual dinners or celebrating something special.
Famous Dishes: Mediterranean-inspired seafood, seasonal plates
Address: 301 Park Ave, Long Beach, NY 11561

Atlantic Beach may be small, but it delivers big flavors, fun vibes, and a local charm that makes every meal memorable. From rustic Italian ovens to elevated sushi, tapas, and classic seafood spots, there’s no shortage of good eats—and maybe a few laughs along the way.

Book your hotels in Atlantic Beach, NY with our curated list for the best stay options without the hassle of searching.

7.8 Good

Best Western Plus Brooklyn Bay Hotel

3003 Emmons Avenue Brooklyn, us

7.6 Good

Apartment Ocean Block

97 West End Avenue 5B Brooklyn, us

8.4 Very good

Best Western Brooklyn-Coney Island Inn

2632 W 13Th St Brooklyn, us